Question 1: Evaluating viewpoints
After the school library added a quiet reading corner, lunchtime borrowing rose during a two-week trial. The principal called the rise proof that the corner had worked. The librarian was more cautious: those weeks had also been unusually cold, keeping more students indoors. 'Let's keep the corner,' she said, 'and compare borrowing during some warmer weeks before we decide how much difference it makes.'
Which statement best describes the librarian's view?
Show answer and explanation for Reading question 1: Evaluating viewpoints
Answer: C. The corner is worth keeping while more evidence is gathered about its effect.
Separate the two viewpoints. The principal treats the increase as proof; the librarian notices a competing explanation: cold weather brought more students indoors.
Her words support both parts of C: keep the corner for now, and gather comparison evidence before judging its effect. She neither rejects the corner nor accepts the trial as proof of its impact.
Why the other options do not work
- A. This is the principal's claim. The librarian identifies the cold weather as another possible explanation and wants a comparison.
- B. The librarian explicitly says, 'Let's keep the corner.' Being cautious about the evidence is not a request to remove it.
- D. She proposes comparing borrowing figures in warmer weeks, so she considers them potentially useful rather than useless.


